Should Malika Sehrawat be allowed to join ?

[anilkc]

She is a Jat and a Hindu Jat. Many in this forum has expressed very strong views about her. So, given a choice that only 1 more can register in forum, who should that 1 Jat be?
The choices:
1) A muslim
2) A Sikh
3) Malika Sehrawat
4) I will leave the forum if any of the above is allowed to join

[sansanwalamit]

It is a very stupid question, and the way it is raised is also very stupid, I know about the above mentioned woman through this website only, the posts regarding that woman also informed me that many of our members were outraged by her skimpy clothes and they had called her vulgar and cheap.
Now how a woman who is considerd cheap or vulgar by some of our own memebrs can be kept at par as a choice with someone belonging to a certain religion.
Please do not put such questions for the sake of putting a question, this brings down the purpose and respect of this forum.

[mukesh_rana80]

Hello anil bhai sahab !
Great question !!
i will go for the fifth choice
5) None of the above

[ravichaudhary]

anil chaudhary (Mar 07, 2004 12:46 a.m.):
She is a Jat and a Hindu Jat. Many in this forum has expressed very strong views about her. So, given a choice that only 1 more can register in forum, who should that 1 Jat be?
The choices:
1) A muslim
2) A Sikh
3) Malika Sehrawat
4) I will leave the forum if any of the above is allowed to join

************

These are very strong views.

Let us discuss them one by one

what has any Sikh done to hurt you ?

Ravi

[anujkumar]

Ravi Chaudhary (Mar 07, 2004 08:11 a.m.):
anil chaudhary (Mar 07, 2004 12:46 a.m.):
She is a Jat and a Hindu Jat. Many in this forum has expressed very strong views about her. So, given a choice that only 1 more can register in forum, who should that 1 Jat be?
The choices:
1) A muslim
2) A Sikh
3) Malika Sehrawat
4) I will leave the forum if any of the above is allowed to join

************

These are very strong views.

Let us discuss them one by one

what has any Sikh done to hurt you ?

Ravi
***********************************

Ravi Jee:

Where are the views you are talking about? and what's strong about them. one by one: how many are there?

What are else are people supposed to tell you..Kee "SIKHO ne Jatto ke bhains khol lee" How does the question "what have any Sikh done to hurt you" is supposed to mean. Dange kurwana chahte ho kya ?

You still haven't got enough masala? Google karlo. aajkal Google pe bhee bahoot maal mil jata hai.

[ravichaudhary]

[quote][b]Anuj

There is also a lot of nonsense on Google, and it is not that difficult to debunk.

If you have specific complaints then we can try and get our Sikh friends to deal with them.

That has nothing to do with whether they can enter the discussion on this site or not.

In fact I will post them for you on your behalf on a Sikh Site.

If you have no specific complaints, but just a general antipathy, then perhaps a little communication with them could also be arranged.

I do know one thing, if some Sikh Jat( or anyone) posted something about Jats, like you have done about Sikhs, I would feel very very hurt.

In fact one of the objectives of the Jathistory
has been to correct misconceptions
about Jats in other communties.

It is hard work. I would like help.

Will you join in to help?

We have had a few success stories too. Those successes did not come because we sulked in a closed room, but because we went out and communicated with others, and encouraged others to become part of the group.

People have started to respect us, the stereotyping has declined.

Look this list _ Jatland is not a confidential list.

I am aware that people ( Non jats) are here on this site with assumed names, and note evrything people like you and me write here.

Now what should we do, go on a witch hunt?

All I am suggesting is bring them out in the open.

People will have misconceptions of each other.

Mostly that is all that it is.

To me it is not a do or die situation if this list opens up or not.

I would like it to, for the reasons I have given.

Best regards

Ravi

[anujkumar]

Ravi Jee:

Sabtai pahle to koi Jat bhai yaa bahan aapki pahooch me ho to is vaikya kaa anuwad karao..

A ne ke B kee ke bhains khol lee .

tub aapkee samaz me aayega kee meri antipathy sirf aapke un saste hathkando se thee Jo aapne iis aur baki do sambandhit posts me apnaye naki kee Sikho yaa musalmano se. Yaa site aapne apne kisi hidden agenda ke tahat cheap anthro experiment karan kee jagah bana lee wo bhee members kee consent ke bina!!

[anilkc]

ummhhh...

[amar0974]

Bhai Anil Sawad le hai........???

[uday]

Integrity of question itself is doubtful.

anil chaudhary (Mar 07, 2004 12:46 a.m.):
She is a Jat and a Hindu Jat. Many in this forum has expressed very strong views about her. So, given a choice that only 1 more can register in forum, who should that 1 Jat be?
The choices:
1) A muslim
2) A Sikh
3) Malika Sehrawat
4) I will leave the forum if any of the above is allowed to join

[yvsgaawar]

Please don't mind. I did not get a single sentence. Can you please explain what u trying to say?



Anuj Kumar (Mar 07, 2004 03:43 p.m.):
Ravi Jee:

Sabtai pahle to koi Jat bhai yaa bahan aapki pahooch me ho to is vaikya kaa anuwad karao..

A ne ke B kee ke bhains khol lee .

tub aapkee samaz me aayega kee meri antipathy sirf aapke un saste hathkando se thee Jo aapne iis aur baki do sambandhit posts me apnaye naki kee Sikho yaa musalmano se. Yaa site aapne apne kisi hidden agenda ke tahat cheap anthro experiment karan kee jagah bana lee wo bhee members kee consent ke bina!!

[anilkc]

This post has been read abt 78 times and thanks to abt 10 memebers who actually taken time to write something. But, none have given the ans. So, my guess is no one cares abt the ans. Specially since, no one has slected-- 4) I will leave the forum if any of the above is allowed to join--I infer that if "others" are allowed to join this forum, life will not end and we all will continue comming to Jatland.com as usual.

[anujkumar]

Aaap sabhee ne "ek anek" wali kavita to suni, hogi bahoot pahle Doordarshan pe aati thee...kya nahee suni to yaha sun lijiye .

http://www.rajiv.com/india/humor/index2.aspx

Uske bad jo aapke man me utsah paida hoga. uske bad hum sub milke is post ko tala laga denge.

[vimal]

Aan do

[anilkc]

go to the original:

http://www.jatland.com/cgi-bin/ub/UltraBoard.cgi?action=Read&BID=4&TID=6896&P=1&SID=76771#ID1

[anilkc]

Jitna samajh mein aya utna clarify karne ki koshish kar raha hoon:
1)Always ask ur studip Qs.
If u do not u will remain one.
If u do, u will be 1 bit smarter.

2) Qs do not have integrity.
Ans have.

3) When in doubt, ask a Q.

[ravichaudhary]

anil chaudhary (Mar 08, 2004 12:08 p.m.):
This post has been read abt 78 times and thanks to abt 10 memebers who actually taken time to write something. But, none have given the ans. So, my guess is no one cares abt the ans. Specially since, no one has slected-- 4) I will leave the forum if any of the above is allowed to join--I infer that if "others" are allowed to join this forum, life will not end and we all will continue comming to Jatland.com as usual.
*************
I misread your riddle/question earlier.

Do keep bringing more mind stimulating questions.

They will improve our ways of looking at things.

My thanks

Ravi

[amitdahiya]

Dear Anil,
When do you and like minded Jats plan to introduce stoning to death as a suitable punishment for women who step out of your definition of the Jat line. I really wish you would drop this line of communication and it surprises me how this kind of crap gets through our topic adminstrator who is otherwise so strict and sensitive even about mentions of the Rental- income- reared- urban-Jats. I think a lot of slip is showing.

[anilkc]

Dear Amit,
I am not sure if u r reading the same post as I am. I have not stated any opinion abt any women or any stones. I have just asked a Q.

The Q is simple and not difficult to understand. Its simple to answer. But once you ponder over your ans it will frighten you, bcos it exposes the "real" cheat in us.
And YES "a lot of slip is showing" by the response I get bcos of this Q.

Let me try to explain the rationale behind the Q as best as I can.
There are very long threads in this forum having heated discussion on following topics:

1) Allowing Sikh JaTs on this site
http://www.jatland.com/cgi-bin/ub/UltraBoard.cgi?action=Read&BID=2&TID=4312&P=1&SID=77595

2) Should Muslim Jats be allowed on this site?
http://www.jatland.com/cgi-bin/ub/UltraBoard.cgi?action=Read&BID=2&TID=4349&P=1&SID=77595

3) The Futile Debacle about Hindu Jats vs. Non-Hindu Jats
http://www.jatland.com/cgi-bin/ub/UltraBoard.cgi?action=Read&BID=2&TID=4447&P=1&SID=77595#ID20

4)There are numeours ones on Malika Sehrawat. The longest one of >250 posts is:
http://www.jatland.com/cgi-bin/ub/UltraBoard.cgi?action=Read&BID=2&TID=2406&P=1&SID=77595

Read through these posts.
Make a choice to ans the question.
Compare your ans with the reason given in above thread.
And then ask urself:
Are the reasons posted in the thread real?
Or, are they a cover up for something deeper?

Think before u come to any conclusion abt any stones. Rest assured, I am not conspiring to stone anybody to anything.

[sansanwalamit]

Dear Anil,
I pointed out at your question and gave my opinion about it, but I guess I could not explain myself well.
I am not just concerned with the question, but its nature as well, I agree that your question might hint towards some deep rooted issues, or deeper meanings behind things, but what is the point for all that?
These arguments and discussions are fun, but then they do get messy and dirty after a while and the moment they do, we should just leave them there and then, which hardly happens, but when it does happen, then I totally do not see any point in restarting them.
All these issues are very much talked about, and I fail to find a common ground among your options, thus I found the nature and the way of your question stupid.
Now, it was just an honest opinion, and I refrained from answering it only because I do not agree with discussing those issues further.
And if you are so concerned about hidden meanings behind what we all say then why do not you start with yourself and instead of putting a question like this, simply post your views and reactions towards how and what people are writing, would not that be great?

[anilkc]

Bahas karne mein hum sab ustad hain. Bahas ka koi ant nahi hai. And who will decide who won the debate or whats the right ans to the Q raised abt membership criteria. My ans is Take a poll and put an end to at least one debate.
Now its time to take a stand and vote and be resposible for it.

We can later on discuss the results.

[amitshokeen]

aray yaar apni bhan ke gayi malika sherawat. chodo piccha usko.