View Full Version : Bhagat singh and Gandhi
piush_tomar
August 4th, 2005, 10:02 PM
Dear Friends,
Though I am a economics (hons) from AMU.But also as I gone through Modern Indian history books which starts from high school to PG..most common thing is that..Its highly influenced and, molded by congress government.
Still you will hardly get the full chapter on bhagat singh,chandrashekar azad and some other great freedom fighter. They (historian) talked about the gandhi's goat and us bakri ki rassi..jo aaj bhi sabermati key ashram mein mozood hey. and all those bull **** what ghandhi used to do..but never mentioned ...woh bhagat singh ka fasi ka fanda..jis par jhool kar un shaheedo ney jaan de...
..Kya humney aaj tak vichar kiya hey is par.
This is becouse..Our system. politician they dont want to teach us bhagat singh ideology..kyoki asia karkey..woh lankhon bhagat singh paida nahi karn chahatey..and this will not be good for them..
I need comment from all my friends on jatland.com .
jitendershooda
August 4th, 2005, 11:00 PM
Haan bhai yeh baat hon lag rahi thi ek thread pe jib hude thodi garma garmi hogi er is baat pe koe reply na aaya ....{jeetendra sinsinwar bhai ki teraf te bhi] ....
http://www.jatland.com/forums/showthread.php?t=9121&page=3&pp=15
SWAMI RAMDEV ...JO YOGA SIKHATE HEIN NE PICHLE SAAL 2 OCT KO EK BAHUT SAHI BAAT KAHI THI ....
" KI AAJ TAK AAPNE KABHI SOCHA HAI IS DESH MEIN AISA KUN HOTA HAI KI JIS RASSE SE GANDHI KI BAKRI BANDHA KARTI THI WO AAPKO AAJ BHI UNKE MUSEUM MEIN MIL JAEGI PAR WO FANSI KA FANDA KAHIN NAHI MILEGA JISSE BHAGAT SINGH , RAJGURU AND SUKHDEV KO FANSI DEE GAEE THI ... "
brad
August 5th, 2005, 05:35 AM
kiya karenge comments leke ?
agar sarkar bhagat singh ke bare mein padhati to ek bhi bhagat singh ke paida hone ki zaroorat nahi padti.
bhagat singh ki zaroorat to aaj hai. hai himmat bhagat singh banane ki?
sarkar Gandhi ji ke bare mein padhati hai...apne bhi padha hoga...agar aap gandhi ke raste bhi chal pade to yeh sarkar sudhar jayegi. dont look around for excuses.
sandeepk
August 5th, 2005, 08:06 AM
the reasoin why govrenment don't want to teach abt. bhagat sing and other reveloutionary freedom fighters is that because govrenment don't want to bring a revelotuion inthe country.at that time gandhiw s quite close to the british raj and few other people were the mainrepresentatives of the indians to the british raj as per my knowledge.so the media was also close to those people a s media wanted to get some real hot news to print. thats why bhagat sing and other revolutionary people remaind behind the secne as their main aim was to gain independence while on the other hand some people had their own vested intrest and wanted them on the front page always. so thats the reason u would see everything about gandhi and nothing about azad and bhagat sing.
brad
August 5th, 2005, 11:39 AM
How do u know so much abt all thes govt conspiracy?
dahiyars
August 5th, 2005, 05:36 PM
Dear Piush Tomar
I agree with you. Bhagat Singh had very clear Vision about the Future India. But the people in power feel endangered with his ideology and that is why they pay only lip sympathies to him and really donot want his ideas to spread further.
Dr R.S.Dahiya
deepakchoudhry
August 5th, 2005, 06:46 PM
They cannot be compared but their contribution to the cause was immense.
They both inspired masses in their own way.
Personally, Gandhi was great visionary, I never consider him to be a politician, he was more of Humanitarian.
He had vision of development at the grass roots first (i.e. our villages) but today majority of Gandhivaad politicians are not bothered (though they are good in coming with great slogans like "India Shining").
Today, The farmers are in a terrible state (except in punjab), After 50 odd years, Life in the villages is still difficult.
Bhagat singh and Gandhi were both action men but their paths were different.
Maybe thats what we need today, Dynamism of Bhagat singh and vision of Gandhi.