On what basis you take a stand on any discussion at JL?

[sjakhars]

It has been more than 6 years when I joined Jatland, have seen many members go, new members come and this cylce continues. I have seen members commenting on several issues and taking stand in discussions. Noticed also that some issues are ignored completely and some are over discussed. A community related, national ineterest issue goes untouched and tricky issues are discussed endlessly. A thought just came into my mind (if I have some) :) that what is the thing which makes Jatlanders to take a stand on any issue/discussion (in support or against)? Issues range from community to national level and even international level. There are few which I can list:

1. Your political affiliations
2. Your knowledge of subject and intelligence
3. Influenced by your friends online/offline

You all are welcome to add more.

[urmiladuhan]

It has been more than 6 years when I joined Jatland, have seen many members go, new members come and this cylce continues. I have seen members commenting on several issues and taking stand in discussions. Noticed also that some issues are ignored completely and some are over discussed. A community related, national ineterest issue goes untouched and tricky issues are discussed endlessly. A thought just came into my mind (if I have some) :) that what is the thing which makes Jatlanders to take a stand on any issue/discussion (in support or against)? Issues range from community to national level and even international level. There are few which I can list:

1. Your political affiliations
2. Your knowledge of subject and intelligence
3. Influenced by your friends online/offline

You all are welcome to add more.

Many times, it is my personal experience on the issue being discussed.

[Arvindc]

Few that comes to my mind....
- Current happenings of fundamental importance, directly or indirectly, impacting the community.
- Participation on threads depends a lot on how the discussions are going on (and sometimes who all are participating, it indirectly reflects the seriousness of the thread).
- How lively the subject matter is, recent example eg Hisar election, Anna movement, etc.
- For creativity, humor, networking.
- For broadening understanding as we get to learn a lot from other members experiences and views.

[nainsunil007]

For some members -
involvement of girls posts:stupid:

[urmiladuhan]

It has been more than 6 years when I joined Jatland, have seen many members go, new members come and this cylce continues. I have seen members commenting on several issues and taking stand in discussions. Noticed also that some issues are ignored completely and some are over discussed. A community related, national ineterest issue goes untouched and tricky issues are discussed endlessly. A thought just came into my mind (if I have some) :) that what is the thing which makes Jatlanders to take a stand on any issue/discussion (in support or against)? Issues range from community to national level and even international level. There are few which I can list:

1. Your political affiliations
2. Your knowledge of subject and intelligence
3. Influenced by your friends online/offline

You all are welcome to add more.

I also think that just as in real life, where men and women come together, the issues mostly discussed with each other depend on one's personal liking and not necessarily on what is politically relevant for the country or what should be done to tackle social problems etc. Mostly, social interaction hovers around light talk and maybe once in a while on heavy, deep thinking stuff - which is what happens on JL too. The things/topics that one thinks are irrelevant to national interests/community problems etc, but are popular items for discussion are actually very important for keeping the community together and keeping the this community place thriving, enjoyable and alive. Calling such discussions irrelevant to the development of the community is, I think, not correct.

[deependra]

It has been more than 6 years when I joined Jatland, have seen many members go, new members come and this cylce continues. I have seen members commenting on several issues and taking stand in discussions. Noticed also that some issues are ignored completely and some are over discussed. A community related, national ineterest issue goes untouched and tricky issues are discussed endlessly. A thought just came into my mind (if I have some) :) that what is the thing which makes Jatlanders to take a stand on any issue/discussion (in support or against)? Issues range from community to national level and even international level. There are few which I can list:

1. Your political affiliations
2. Your knowledge of subject and intelligence
3. Influenced by your friends online/offline

You all are welcome to add more.

I think there are multiple factors which contirbute for a person to make him participate in the discussion. First and the most important is the knowledge and awareness on the issue being discussed. Sometimes, even if the posts are interesting but lack of the knowledge in that area holds back a member to participate. Sometimes people participate to just set their personal rants against somebody, but the ratio is quite low.

[amankadian]

It has been more than 6 years when I joined Jatland, have seen many members go, new members come and this cylce continues. I have seen members commenting on several issues and taking stand in discussions. Noticed also that some issues are ignored completely and some are over discussed. A community related, national ineterest issue goes untouched and tricky issues are discussed endlessly. A thought just came into my mind (if I have some) :) that what is the thing which makes Jatlanders to take a stand on any issue/discussion (in support or against)? Issues range from community to national level and even international level. There are few which I can list:

1. Your political affiliations
2. Your knowledge of subject and intelligence
3. Influenced by your friends online/offline

You all are welcome to add more.
Very Nice thread
Thanks a lot sir
I am really sorry about this
" Yha pe kafi thread sirf asie hote hai jin pe discussion jayda hota hai per wo kisi kaam ke nhi hote. Muje jha tak pata hai ki post sirf Jatland members ya fir sirf jaat hi read nhi karte jabki Guest bhi kafi visit karte hai is site ko Jo non jat hote hai. Ager visitors ko kuch or acche topic ya information yha se milegi to wo jayda visit karege site ko"

[deshi-jat]

Sitaram Ji, I would calculate something like this;

1. Your political affiliations =10%
2. Your knowledge of subject and intelligence =20%
3. Influenced by your friends online/offline = 25%

4. Personal grudge = 10%
5. Nostalgia = 20%
6. Show off = 5%
7. Miscellaneous =10%




It has been more than 6 years when I joined Jatland, have seen many members go, new members come and this cylce continues. I have seen members commenting on several issues and taking stand in discussions. Noticed also that some issues are ignored completely and some are over discussed. A community related, national ineterest issue goes untouched and tricky issues are discussed endlessly. A thought just came into my mind (if I have some) :) that what is the thing which makes Jatlanders to take a stand on any issue/discussion (in support or against)? Issues range from community to national level and even international level. There are few which I can list:

1. Your political affiliations
2. Your knowledge of subject and intelligence
3. Influenced by your friends online/offline

You all are welcome to add more.

[ravinderjeet]

में ते टेम पास करण आया करूँ |
अर कई नए दोस्त बणाया करूँ |
हांसी-हान्सियाँ में कई बसाए हसन गढ़ ,
थोड़ा भोत ज्ञान भी कट्ठा कर ले जाया करूं |

[deependra]

में ते टेम पास करण आया करूँ |
अर कई नए दोस्त बणाया करूँ |
हांसी-हान्सियाँ में कई बसाए हसन गढ़ ,
थोड़ा भोत ज्ञान भी कट्ठा कर ले जाया करूं |

I don't agree with you bhaisahab, you do more on JL than simple time pass. Your posts are really helpful in increasing knowledge about our jat culture, traditions and slangs...

[deshi-jat]

"जट्टा की रसोई " !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! टेम पास कोनी इतनी खुबात करके लिखणा :topsy_turvy:


में ते टेम पास करण आया करूँ |
अर कई नए दोस्त बणाया करूँ |
हांसी-हान्सियाँ में कई बसाए हसन गढ़ ,
थोड़ा भोत ज्ञान भी कट्ठा कर ले जाया करूं |

[ravinderjeet]

I don't agree with you bhaisahab, you do more on JL than simple time pass. Your posts are really helpful in increasing knowledge about our jat culture, traditions and slangs...

धन्यवाद दीपेंदर भाई | पर में ते जिन्दगी की भुक्तभोगी जाणकारी के अनुसार लिख दयूं सूं | पर इह तें भी किहे का ज्ञान बध जा स ते आछी-ए बात स | बाकी मन्ने ते ,वो के कहया करें अंग्रेजी में "वोर्किंग नोलेज "ए स शायद | हाँ ,शायद न्यू-ए कहया करें हाळी-पालियाँ के ज्ञान ने ,वो-ए स बस |


हा हा हा ,भाई इह कल्चर अर ट्रेडीसन में स्लेंग भी ते आजावें सें ,न्यारा बताण का कोए ख़ास उद्देश्य था के ?

[vicky84]

"जट्टा की रसोई " !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! टेम पास कोनी इतनी खुबात करके लिखणा :topsy_turvy:

arr albaadi kissey arr Haryanwi paheli reh gi wo nyari.

[deependra]

हा हा हा ,भाई इह कल्चर अर ट्रेडीसन में स्लेंग भी ते आजावें सें ,न्यारा बताण का कोए ख़ास उद्देश्य था के ?

haan, aapka ek dhaga tha, naam yaad nahi aa raha poora shayad- haryanvi ke anokhe shabd......

[jagmohan]

Dear Jatlanders.

RAM RAM,

I have always kept the following in mind while posting or participating:

1. Contribute positively to a subject that I think I know about. I have never felt it necessary to comment on every subject.

2. Think before commenting. If a member disagrees with me, I will try and give my point of view or clarify a comment one more time.

3. Never got personal.

4. Give equal respect to all genders.

5. Try and share my knowledge and experience for whatever worth it is.

6. Never commenting on anyone’s character, social status or educational background.

7. Never being a know all. One can learn from everyone; elders and youngsters.

With regards,

JS Malik

[Arvindc]

...
5. Nostalgia = 20%
...


Nostalgia for what???

[Sure]

What seems logical and true according to our own experience. That may be wrong or right but by keeping a point polietly what I try.


haan kuch ek aadtein hain ki samajh mein bhi nahi aata aur mantein bhi nahi, Just because we are Jaaaaat but I am in full support in changing this habit

[JSRana]

भाई जाखड साहब मैं भी यहाँ मनोरंजन के साथ साथ ज्ञान साँझा साँझा के लिए आता हूँ | मेरी सोच है कि ज्ञान कहीं से और किसी से भी लिया जा सकता है बशर्ते आप अपना रवैया सकारात्मक रखे | ईस के लिए थोडा "मैं" को रोक के रखना पड़ता है | सही बताऊँ मैंने पिछले तीन महीने मैं ईस फोरम से काफी कुछ सीखा है और कुछ बहूत अच्छे लोगों से सम्बन्ध भी बनाया है |

धन्यवाद् सहित |

[sjakhars]

Thank you Krishan Ji. My intention was to get this type of information. For me, personal grudges and political affiliations are higher than what you have calculated.

Here, political affiliations, personal grudge and influence of friends makes more than 50%. Does that mean we do not actually look at what is being said?

Mostly, we look at who is saying and about whom it is being said. Does this attitude hit the quality of our discussions?


Sitaram Ji, I would calculate something like this;

1. Your political affiliations =10%
2. Your knowledge of subject and intelligence =20%
3. Influenced by your friends online/offline = 25%

4. Personal grudge = 10%
5. Nostalgia = 20%
6. Show off = 5%
7. Miscellaneous =10%

[urmiladuhan]

Thank you Krishan Ji. My intention was to get this type of information. For me, personal grudges and political affiliations are higher than what you have calculated.

Here, political affiliations, personal grudge and influence of friends makes more than 50%. Does that mean we do not actually look at what is being said?

Mostly, we look at who is saying and about whom it is being said. Does this attitude hit the quality of our discussions?

Fully agree. I have experienced people being part of a group and when their situation demands, these groupies gang up on one person (even if it is a woman) for verbal bashings.

[deshi-jat]

Sentimental yearning for former place, time, food, outmoded instruments, etc. It is frequently reflected in many threads/posts.



Nostalgia for what???

[deshi-jat]

Sitaram ji,
I have been active since last few months, so my personal experience is very limited as compared to you.

Yes most of us see and judge the topic though glass of prejudice and comment accordingly, and it definitely degrades the quality of discussion.


Thank you Krishan Ji. My intention was to get this type of information. For me, personal grudges and political affiliations are higher than what you have calculated.

Here, political affiliations, personal grudge and influence of friends makes more than 50%. Does that mean we do not actually look at what is being said?

Mostly, we look at who is saying and about whom it is being said. Does this attitude hit the quality of our discussions?

[satyenderdeswal]

bhai...
jaat hain...itna na sochya karte..[
jit jo likhan ka jee karey hai ya share karan ka jee karey hai, wohi kar de hain ;)QUOTE=jakhar77;289885]It has been more than 6 years when I joined Jatland, have seen many members go, new members come and this cylce continues. I have seen members commenting on several issues and taking stand in discussions. Noticed also that some issues are ignored completely and some are over discussed. A community related, national ineterest issue goes untouched and tricky issues are discussed endlessly. A thought just came into my mind (if I have some) :) that what is the thing which makes Jatlanders to take a stand on any issue/discussion (in support or against)? Issues range from community to national level and even international level. There are few which I can list:

1. Your political affiliations
2. Your knowledge of subject and intelligence
3. Influenced by your friends online/offline

You all are welcome to add more.[/QUOTE]

[malikdeepak1]

Mai us discussion me part nahi leta jit ghani badi badi baat hoti ho (jit ghani angreji me likh deve se wa bhi mere khatir to badi e baat ho jya se :cool:). Manoranjan ke liye behtreen site hai ye. Upar te Mahamaheem Shri Ravinderjeet balhara dwaara swarn-aksharo me likhi gayi unki ar gullu ki albaad or gaon se judi baate! Baki aade serious discussion me ghna maja na aata.. Ek adhi baat kahke mai to likhan te kanni kaat jaaya karu ise taagya te..knowledge jarur badhe hai aade kuch serious discussions te.Kuch baata ka kade bera na nahi hota wo bhi bera paat jya se.
Par fer log khonsde bjaan laag jya se to ude to ram-rami apni te.



PS : Ek-adha manas "CHASKE" me bhi aaya kare. Ya social-networking sites bhi ek tariya ka NASHAA kare se.. Jisne suwwad aa jya is nashe me, uska CHASKA aape kheench laya kare oohne! :very_drunk:

[ravinderjeet]

Sentimental yearning for former place, time, food (e.g. bajre ki khichdi), outmoded instruments, etc. It is frequently reflected in many threads/posts.

चोखा र कर्शन तन्ने बता दिया, ना ते में यु नोस्लेजिया खेर(जुकाम ) ने समझूँ था |

[deshi-jat]

चलो कीमै तो फायदा हुया


चोखा र कर्शन तन्ने बता दिया, ना ते में यु नोस्लेजिया खेर(जुकाम ) ने समझूँ था |

[ravinderjeet]

चलो कीमै तो फायदा हुया


हाँ भाई मेरा खेर ठीक होग्या |

[deshi-jat]

ले भाई रविंदर, आपने बाजरे की खीचड़ी का एतराज़ था तो खल्लास कर दी. वैसे मैंने आपको केंद्र रख के कुछ नहीं लिख्या था


हाँ भाई मेरा खेर ठीक होग्या |

[ravinderjeet]

ले भाई रविंदर, आपने बाजरे की खीचड़ी का एतराज़ था तो खल्लास कर दी. वैसे मैंने आपको केंद्र रख के कुछ नहीं लिख्या था

में कद कहूँ सूं अक आपने में केंद्र में धर के ने लिखा था ,में ते तागे के बोझ ने हल्का करूँ था ,मखा किम्मे हान्स ल्यां |

[urmiladuhan]

Sitaram ji,
I have been active since last few months, so my personal experience is very limited as compared to you.

Yes most of us see and judge the topic though glass of prejudice and comment accordingly, and it definitely degrades the quality of discussion.



well said!

[urmiladuhan]

ले भाई रविंदर, आपने बाजरे की खीचड़ी का एतराज़ था तो खल्लास कर दी. वैसे मैंने आपको केंद्र रख के कुछ नहीं लिख्या था

या ego ना टिककण देन्ती! it can delusion one to think he/she is the talk of the town!

[rakeshsehrawat]

में ते टेम पास करण आया करूँ |
अर कई नए दोस्त बणाया करूँ |
हांसी-हान्सियाँ में कई बसाए हसन गढ़ ,
थोड़ा भोत ज्ञान भी कट्ठा कर ले जाया करूं |
Apni bhi nyu ki nyu

[ravinderjeet]

Apni bhi nyu ki nyu

डाकि , तू भी कसुता पड्या स | के ते सुआल करें जावेगा अर के न्यू की न्यू कह के ने रह जा गा | किम्मे औरां ने भी ज्ञान दे दिया कर, ले-ले के ने भाज ले | लोगाँ के चिरडाण माच जा स जब तू जबाब ना देंदा |

[rakeshsehrawat]

डाकि , तू भी कसुता पड्या स | के ते सुआल करें जावेगा अर के न्यू की न्यू कह के ने रह जा गा | किम्मे औरां ने भी ज्ञान दे दिया कर, ले-ले के ने भाज ले | लोगाँ के चिरडाण माच जा स जब तू जबाब ना देंदा |

Isa hai Ravinder ji pehlam quality department mein tha. Ude ek analysis hoya kare 5W1H ya Why Why ya what? When? Where? Why? Who? and How? kise bhi samasya ki jad mein jaan khater. Mein wo format bhara karta ar workara pe sawal pooche jaya karta jab tahi we GMne rooka maar ke na bula lete ki ji yu kaam na karan deta. Ib wa adat kharab isi ho rahi hai jab tahi log ardan nahi lag jate mera format poora e na bhara jata.

[urmiladuhan]

लोगाँ के चिरडाण माच जा स जब तू जबाब ना देंदा |

It is not easy to answer on JL without having wits!

[rakeshsehrawat]

It is not easy to answer on JL without having wits!
You will hardly find any question to use your wits on jatland.
:-)

[ravinderjeet]

You will hardly find any question to use your wits on jatland.
:-)


:triumphant::triumphant::triumphant::triumphant:

[urmiladuhan]

You will hardly find any question to use your wits on jatland.
:-)

seems this is the best you got!!!! laughable!

[urmiladuhan]

Apni bhi nyu ki nyu

there goes the "group"! Ravinder- Rakesh jodee!

[ravinderjeet]

http://a1.sphotos.ak.fbcdn.net/hphotos-ak-ash4/375812_251483088239268_193785154009062_655195_1270 729594_n.jpg



beraa naa log k chaahwein sein aade .

[urmiladuhan]

http://a1.sphotos.ak.fbcdn.net/hphotos-ak-ash4/375812_251483088239268_193785154009062_655195_1270 729594_n.jpg


who says you wake up everyday?!

[urmiladuhan]

[QUOTE=ravinderjeet;2



beraa naa log k chaahwein sein aade .[/QUOTE]

no wonder you hang out with Rakeshjee - he too is full of questions but no answers!!! :)

[rakeshsehrawat]

But i hardly starts any thread to find any solutions/answers to those questions.

[ravinderjeet]

But i hardly starts any thread to find any solutions/answers to those questions.


फेर सफाई देण की के जरूत स तन्ने | बोझड़याँ में सर देणा जरूरी स के ?

[Fateh]

I take stand on the bases of facts, truth and against injustice, false accusation, insulting and mischievious posts. Regards

[Samarkadian]

It has been more than 6 years when I joined Jatland, have seen many members go, new members come and this cylce continues. I have seen members commenting on several issues and taking stand in discussions. Noticed also that some issues are ignored completely and some are over discussed. A community related, national ineterest issue goes untouched and tricky issues are discussed endlessly. A thought just came into my mind (if I have some) :) that what is the thing which makes Jatlanders to take a stand on any issue/discussion (in support or against)? Issues range from community to national level and even international level. There are few which I can list:

1. Your political affiliations
2. Your knowledge of subject and intelligence
3. Influenced by your friends online/offline

You all are welcome to add more.

I take a stand on any issue ( offline or online) based on my mental make up irrespective of disliking or liking by others.

[urmiladuhan]

But i hardly starts any thread to find any solutions/answers to those questions.

yes coz that requires wits!

[urmiladuhan]

फेर सफाई देण की के जरूत स तन्ने | बोझड़याँ में सर देणा जरूरी स के ?

you won't understand coz it is battle of wits! even then, you are welcome to watch.