PDA

View Full Version : Separate General History Forum need of the hour.



DrRajpalSingh
April 21st, 2013, 10:23 AM
The Jatland.com has traversed a long way since its inception and the membership and the interest of the participates has also multiplied over the years. Is it not worthwhile to redesign its main page 'Forum' to suit the need of the changing times.

Presently Jat Land Forum with three sub forums clubbed under 'Special Interest' contains one of them christened as 'Jat History'. But, it has been observed that under this section several other topics which are either slightly related directly or indirectly with Jat History or at times not at all related with it, have been taken for discussion.

It would be appreciated that a separate History or General History forum, sub-forum may be started to give a fair chance to discuss both the topics at their respective places viz topics related exclusively with Jat History in the existing place and all other issues concerning regional, state, continental and world history may be discussed in the new proposed section.

If this bifurcation is implemented, it is hoped, the discussions would flow smoothly in right direction without facing avoidable disruptions and irrelevant questions which derail the very purpose of the threads started for serious discussions.

Views of the members are welcome to discuss the feasibility of implementation of the suggestion.

Regards

lrburdak
April 22nd, 2013, 08:37 AM
This is a good suggestion by Dr Rajpalji and Admins to look into the matter.

VPannu
April 22nd, 2013, 10:36 AM
The Jatland.com has traversed a long way since its inception and the membership and the interest of the participates has also multiplied over the years. Is it not worthwhile to redesign its main page 'Forum' to suit the need of the changing times.

Presently Jat Land Forum with three sub forums clubbed under 'Special Interest' contains one of them christened as 'Jat History'. But, it has been observed that under this section several other topics which are either slightly related directly or indirectly with Jat History or at times not at all related with it, have been taken for discussion.

It would be appreciated that a separate History or General History forum, sub-forum may be started to give a fair chance to discuss both the topics at their respective places viz topics related exclusively with Jat History in the existing place and all other issues concerning regional, state, continental and world history may be discussed in the new proposed section.

If this bifurcation is implemented, it is hoped, the discussions would flow smoothly in right direction without facing avoidable disruptions and irrelevant questions which derail the very purpose of the threads started for serious discussions.

Views of the members are welcome to discuss the feasibility of implementation of the suggestion.

RegardsI don't think more than 10 members participate actively in history section. "soot na kapaas julaaho me guttham guttha" . No one comes with solid evidence of anything. I don't think it is necessary. But yeah, lets have it just for the heck of it because we also have 'Rajasthani Music' and 'Sports' forum here.

DrRajpalSingh
April 22nd, 2013, 03:40 PM
I don't think more than 10 members participate actively in history section. "soot na kapaas julaaho me guttham guttha" . No one comes with solid evidence of anything. I don't think it is necessary. But yeah, lets have it just for the heck of it because we also have 'Rajasthani Music' and 'Sports' forum here.


Welcome Friend,

Permit me to add here that the purpose of the present suggestion is just to improve the quality of content and smooth flow of discussion. Do you not think that segregation of the Jat History Sub Forum and General History Forum could lead towards achieving that end.

Friend if you care to read the posts in sub-forum entitled 'Jat History' and Wiki section you will find that literary, traditions, archaeological, numismatic, carbon dating and so many latest sources and means of reconstruction of history have been used by the pains-taking scholars since the days of very inception of the jatland.com--special interest.

As a result of it, many a new points regarding past history of the Jats in particular and history of mankind in general have been brought to light to fill the gaps.

Also pause and think would it not be good to judge the quality and not the quantity of scholarly work being made available to all the users by a few members.

It is hoped that more members would join healthy and serious scholarly discussion if the hiccups in discussion are removed by bifurcation of the topics into two separate Forums.


I think after looking at the total contribution of the members to this section, you will revise your current opinion on the issue.

Thanks and regards

neetu21
April 23rd, 2013, 09:18 PM
Would it be fine if a separate "History" forum is created with "General History" and "Jat History" as its sub-forums?


The Jatland.com has traversed a long way since its inception and the membership and the interest of the participates has also multiplied over the years. Is it not worthwhile to redesign its main page 'Forum' to suit the need of the changing times.
Presently Jat Land Forum with three sub forums clubbed under 'Special Interest' contains one of them christened as 'Jat History'. But, it has been observed that under this section several other topics which are either slightly related directly or indirectly with Jat History or at times not at all related with it, have been taken for discussion.
It would be appreciated that a separate History or General History forum, sub-forum may be started to give a fair chance to discuss both the topics at their respective places viz topics related exclusively with Jat History in the existing place and all other issues concerning regional, state, continental and world history may be discussed in the new proposed section.
If this bifurcation is implemented, it is hoped, the discussions would flow smoothly in right direction without facing avoidable disruptions and irrelevant questions which derail the very purpose of the threads started for serious discussions.
Regards

bsbana
April 23rd, 2013, 11:51 PM
Would it be fine if a separate "History" forum is created with "General History" and "Jat History" as its sub-forums?

Jaton ka itihas hi to duniya ka itihash hai ;)

DrRajpalSingh
April 24th, 2013, 07:37 AM
Would it be fine if a separate "History" forum is created with "General History" and "Jat History" as its sub-forums?

Absolutely workable formula !

lrburdak
April 24th, 2013, 09:26 AM
Good suggestion of Neetu Ji

History should not be included "Special Interest" forum but a separate "History Forum" which will include "General History" and"Jat History" as its sub forums.

Regards,

sivach
April 24th, 2013, 02:56 PM
इस विचार से सहमत हूँ और एक सुझाव देना चाहता हूँ अब तक की जितनी भी Thread History से related है वो सब भी History Forum में transfer कर दी जाए तो जानकारी लेना आसान हो जायेगा

neetu21
April 25th, 2013, 10:51 PM
There is a separate "History" forum now, with "General History" and "Jat History" as its sub-forums.

rinkusheoran
April 26th, 2013, 04:01 AM
There is a separate "History" forum now, with "General History" and "Jat History" as its sub-forums.


will we be having threads in general history :)

narenderkharb
April 26th, 2013, 05:52 AM
There is a separate "History" forum now, with "General History" and "Jat History" as its sub-forums.


Thanks for a nice suggestion and prompt action.

DrRajpalSingh
April 26th, 2013, 11:57 AM
Thanks to all concerned for having done the needful in the matter of creating separate Forum with two sub-forums for the discussion of 'History'.

It is hoped that now onwards, the discussions would follow smoother course without avoidable hiccups.

Kindly join to prove the usefulness of the act and worth of the faith reposed by the administrators in implementing the suggestions put by all the concerned members.

DrRajpalSingh
April 28th, 2013, 11:19 AM
will we be having threads in general history :)

Of course, Yes.

Join and contribute please !