PDA

View Full Version : Indian nurses' American dream-- Next wave of immigration



amar
September 5th, 2003, 01:37 AM
Article appeared in BBC online.

This is 100 percent true . For the first time the Commission on Graduates of Foreign Nursing schools (CGFNS) test are being held in Bangalore India .Earlier it was only possible to take the exam in Manila or Colombo. The next wave of immigration to America from India will be in nursing and teaching. So suggest the career to your friends, wives, sisters, brothers and all relatives. Great career good life. South India is already awake and moving . I hope some one responsible can open the university doors to Nursing .
Best of Luck


Indian nurses' American dream

By Habib Beary
BBC correspondent in Bangalore



Nursing students come from across India to train
Melody D'sa is ecstatic. Her dream has come true - a new life in America.
Melody is among hundreds of Indian nurses heading to the States, cashing in on a growing demand for trained nurses in the US.

The US, UK and Australia have all looked to India to provide nurses because of shortages of staff.

The dream of working abroad has spawned a slew of training centres in India.

Melody was taught at one of the popular training schools, Nurses Anytime in Bangalore, which recruits for hospitals in the US.


I am looking forward to a new life out there

Melody D'sa
She believes she is ready for the challenges of moving to the US with her family.

"I have always wanted to go abroad. I am looking forward to a new life out there."

Her confidence springs out of having worked for nearly 15 years in major Indian hospitals including St Martha's in Bangalore.

Like Melody, convent-educated Gloria Mohinani is also on her way to the US.

"The money is good. We will have a better life," said Gloria, whose husband and child are going too.

Financial incentive

"We will be paid $30 an hour in the US. Here the average salary for nurses is about 6,000 rupees ($120) a month," said Melody.

Indian nurses working in the US are paid on par with their American counterparts, meaning they take home around $3,000 plus a month.

That is reflected in the tide of applications at these training schools which have sprung up across southern India including in Bangalore, Bombay, Cochin, Coimbotore and Hyderabad.

Revathi Sunkara, director of Indian operations of Nurses Anytime, said: "They are fed up with the poor pay here. The opportunity of a good life is tempting."

Indian nurses are better equipped in terms of medical knowledge

Revathi Sunkara, Nurses Anytime
Nurses who pass the course get a Green Card, their airfare, temporary housing and healthcare benefits.

The lure of money is driving hordes of nurses from the coastal state of Kerala, where most Indian nurses hail from, to these training schools.

Over 10,000 nurses are said to be counting on jobs in the West, Middle-East, Singapore, Australia and New Zealand.

These institutes make them "ready to go".

The training centres charge the trainees between $250 and $300.

Indian nurses are following in the footsteps of computer professionals, thousands of whom left India to make their homes in the US.

Marriage prospects

Jainy John and Leny Matthew, both in their early 20s, are doing a two-month course along with 70 other aspirants at Nurses Anytime.

"There is a rush, everybody wants to go the US," said Jainy.

Indian nurses are coming from as far away as the Gulf to receive training so they can move abroad.


Training for a new life
Candidates complete English language courses and the Commission on Graduates of Foreign Nursing schools (CGFNS) test before they enter the US.

The training programme includes cross-culture etiquette, accent orientation, intonation, and smart grooming.

The trainees are also made computer literate.

"The tests are tough but we are working hard. If I pass, it means a new life for us," said Jainy.

It also means a great demand for them in the marriage market.

Why India?

The US began to look at India as a source for nurses when the flow from Canada, Ireland and the Philippines dried up.

It is estimated that the US faces a shortage of 500,000 nurses.

Revathi Sunkara said the US approached India because of the qualities of the nurses there.

"Drive and dedication. Our nurses are hardworking."

The demand for nurses in the US is growing owing to the increasing number of senior citizens.

Ms Sunkara said: "There is a huge elderly population who need medical care. Indian nurses are better equipped in terms of medical knowledge.

"Our curriculum is on par with that of the US.''

The UK is also recruiting Indian nurses. More than 1,800 nurses joined the NHS in Britain last year.

Narayana Hrudayalaya, a specialist heart care hospital in Bangalore, is in talks with the British Columbia Institute of Technology in Canada to train nurses for recruitment in the overseas market.

Patients from neighbouring countries - Pakistan, Bangladesh and Sri Lanka - flock to this hospital because of the quality of treatment it offers.

satyeshwar
September 5th, 2003, 08:51 PM
Great post Amar. One question though, why is becoming a Nurse still considered a taboo in India? I know for a fact, that people would go to any ends to send their daughters to anything but nursing.

-Satyeshwar

preity
September 10th, 2003, 01:15 AM
Note what you wrote: ‘people would go to any ends to send their daughters to anything but nursing’- what about men? Wouldn’t you say the same about men?

Remember that the nursing profession is women-dominated in both India and US.

To answer your question (I have lived in US most of my life so my view on this might be different than someone in India):

There is nothing more rewarding than a patient giving thanks and telling you how much you have helped them. Also, there are so many opportunities and career paths that are available for Nurses (i.e.; teaching, research, administrative, management, etc.) There will be even more job opportunities in the future. However, the negative aspects are just too many: short staffing due to managed care and cost cutting, liability issues, physically back-breaking work, standing on your feet all the time, long hours (mandatory weekend shifts), exposure to diseases, hostile patients and family members, low pay (yes low pay for the job duties). There is a high turnover rate among nurses and many have gone to pursue other careers. Very few of the nurses that have switched careers want to come back. Despite the heavy recruitment and increase in salary for nurses, the US needs to call nurses from other countries. Lastly, there are so many other better career options available for women. Why should they choose nursing?

I think that the nursing profession in India must be very different than in US in terms of roles and responsibilities (maybe it is not as stressful). A friend of mine decided not to work as a nurse (RN) in US because of the stressful working conditions.


Priti

jagmohan
September 11th, 2003, 02:28 PM
Dear Amar, Priti and Satyeshwar,

Thanks for the information Amar. The querry by Satyeshwar is genuine. Reply and thoughts of Priti are indicative of the fact that nursing profession is a tough job indeed.

The fact is that our sisters hardly have a choice of profession in India. When I say India, I refer to the millions who live in villages and small towns. Believe you me they do not have a choice. They will adapt themselves to which ever profession comes their way, if at all.

Nursing profession demands total dedication and hardwork, qualities sadly lacking today. The minute you say 'Nurse' we think of no one else but Florence Nightingale. Do we have people (Male and Female) as dedicated as her today. Maybe yes or maybe not. The point is there are girls out there in the villages who are ready to become nurses, even though it may be looked down upon in the society. But they still would choose the profession, even if it is for escaping from the grind of lifelong household slavery.

It is good that the west is opening up the doors for nurses and teachers. We should make the best of this offer. My fear is that our JATNI's and JAT's should not get left out just because the nursing profession is looked down upon. If we understand the true meaning of dignity of labour, no job is small. And 'ADAPTABILITY' is our forte.

Spread the word.

Lt Col JS Malik (Retd)
JAT BALWAN, JAI BHAGWAN

anilkc
September 18th, 2003, 01:49 AM
With Delhi being the new cgfns center, i think the awareness about nursing as career and as an tool to move to USA will increase among the Jats. I have started a nurse staffing firm in USA. If any Jats wants to pursue nursing career in USA, they are welcome to contact me. A help from jat doctors in USA who can sponser them in USA is higly welcomed. Please visit www.kardea.com for details.

anujkumar
September 18th, 2003, 11:36 AM
There was report today on BBC that this immigration of nurses from India to west has created a huge shortage on Nurses in India (and other eastern countries). Is that a problem?

As Prity pointed out Nursing doesn't stand so well as a profession on the rewards as compared to what you have to put in, though it is arguable that real rewards here are actually satisfaction that one gets to help someone suffering. If one filters out all the gender bias that exist for any profession against women in India and the fact it is not the best thing to do to make a living, i don't think it is taboo, but for some cultures (like Jats) the work itself could be too hard to handle.

It is not correct to say that there are no opportunities in India, Immigration of a handful of people (nurses) wouldn't uplift the masses, we are talking about here. Only because west has opened the "doors", should we lure people to go for nursing, meaning "become a nurse.. So that you can enter US, rather that a Doctor which is too competitive (to enter US)" and on top of it, people don't have a clear image of things here as they have a exotic image of the west before they head on.

In my personal views, It is wrong to advocate it for the sake of west, which could well be tangential to anybody else views.
Anuj



Jagmohan Singh Malik (Sep 11, 2003 04:58 a.m.):
Dear Amar, Priti and Satyeshwar,

Thanks for the information Amar. The querry by Satyeshwar is genuine. Reply and thoughts of Priti are indicative of the fact that nursing profession is a tough job indeed.

The fact is that our sisters hardly have a choice of profession in India. When I say India, I refer to the millions who live in villages and small towns. Believe you me they do not have a choice. They will adapt themselves to which ever profession comes their way, if at all.

Nursing profession demands total dedication and hardwork, qualities sadly lacking today. The minute you say 'Nurse' we think of no one else but Florence Nightingale. Do we have people (Male and Female) as dedicated as her today. Maybe yes or maybe not. The point is there are girls out there in the villages who are ready to become nurses, even though it may be looked down upon in the society. But they still would choose the profession, even if it is for escaping from the grind of lifelong household slavery.

It is good that the west is opening up the doors for nurses and teachers. We should make the best of this offer. My fear is that our JATNI's and JAT's should not get left out just because the nursing profession is looked down upon. If we understand the true meaning of dignity of labour, no job is small. And 'ADAPTABILITY' is our forte.

Spread the word.

Lt Col JS Malik (Retd)
JAT BALWAN, JAI BHAGWAN

anilkc
September 18th, 2003, 09:18 PM
India may have shortage of money or Onions..but humans...never. The shortage story is being spread by nurse unions in UK to make it difficult for UK hospitals to hire foreign nurse. So now the hospitals have to prove that the country from where they are hiring has no shortage of nurses. So far no country has been certified as having nurse shortage except UK, USA, Austratlia, gulf countries etc.