Any football team in the world plays to win or to entertain I am not sure. I think it is wise for any team to play more on their strengths. For Italy that is defence and counter-attack. 2006 was an exception where the Azzurris played very fast 'controlled' football. Maybe Zambrotta and Gattuso were who brought change. They run all over the pitch and all the time.
Zizou is one of my favourites too. He played for the mighty Juventus for 5-6 years. But, I am sorry to say that you had to evaluate Italian football with Matterazzi example. Personally I think he is the weakest link for the Azzurris. And please try to understand provocation happens in all sports even though it is unethical. That is how the world is. We got to live with it. What do you think about the Saudi Arabia player who got a kick on his butt from Zidane in 98 World cup. Zizou was suspended for two matches after that incident. Its been 10 years and I think that Saudi player would still be wondering as to why Zizou had to hit him. And what about his time in Real Madrid and even Juventus when he headbutted, side kicked, butt kicked, etc etc. Zidane was a superhuman footabller... I do not deny that... I admire him a lot ....but got to accept his anger management needed a lot to work upon.
Akshay, you say that Italians had planned that strategy against Zidane ... I am not sure if you watched the match ... try to remember the time he was provoked. The match was almost running for penalties. Anyways... don't you think that in the finals Pirlo overshadowed Zizou in midfield. Actually, he did. Everyone from the Azzurri side got appreciated a lot after the tournament. But if I were to judge the player of the tournament I would have chosen Pirlo over Cannavaro. Every single match Pirlo was almost perfect.
Zizou is one of the top to have ever played. No doubts!! The French side was playing pathetic till second round when Zidane took everything on himself and guided them to the finals. Final match Zizou wasn't that great and midfield was controlled mostly by Pirlo. Italians were lucky to have won against Australia.