NRI vs Resident Indians !!!

[kapdal]

1) in Realty A Indian is a Indian there is nothing called resident indian or Non resident Indian. These are banking terms.

JO SIRF APNE LIYE JEETA HAI WOH TO FOREIGN MEIN JAKE BAS JAYE BUT JAHAN RAHE WOH WAHIN KA, INDIA KA NAHI. JISS TARAH EK MAA HOTI HAI WAISE HI EK DESH HOTA HAI. NRI KHUD DECIDE KARE WOH KISS DESH KE HAI.

Yaar tune chhap to itna sab diya, par ek baat palle nahin padi. Tu start mein keh raha tha ki Indian is Indian, there is no RI or NRI. Aur fir end mein waapas wahi ki ko jahaan pe rehta hai woh wahin ka, India ka nahin. To sabse pehle to tu apna confusion clear karr le ki NRI Indian hain ki nahin. Aur fir apni understanding ko apne paas rakh. Kyunki tu Bharat ka passport ya PIO card nahin deta, jo dete hain, woh NRIs ko Indian maan ke bahut khush hain.

Aur teri objection kya hai? Aisa kya karr diya NRIs ne jisse desh ka nuksaan hua ho? Post #35 padh liyo jismain maine faayde bataaye hain. Apne mann se nahin banaaye. Reserve Bank of India ki site pe jaake dekh lena, NRIs ko kitni importance di jaati hai. As they are a crucial cog in the Indian economy.

[kapdal]

Bahut badia likha hai bhai.

But this money flows to India because of capability of Indian market to generate returns, U can compare Bank Interest rates in Uk & India, GDP growth rates, foreign currency dep. . Ye to paise ki destiny hai India me aana.

Yes, I said the same in my post. But that is true for "Foreign Deposits" and "Investments". I have separated those from the remittances number in my post. The 50bn dollar number in my post, which is 4% of GDP is "Unrequited Private Transfers" and "Withdrawls from foreign deposits", and has nothing to do with Indian markets. This is because this money is sent for the benefit of the migrants' relatives back home, who use it for consumption or expenditure. In other words, a migrant would send money back as long as he considers that as his primary home and is taking care of the people in that home.

The report whose link I have given in my post, gives the data from 1990 and shows how the remittances have always been a significant percentage of Indian GDP, notwithstanding the turbulances in Indian markets. In fact, the variation in remittances should be more linked to the world economy than Indian economy as the migrants' income is linked to world economy. While that is the case in theory, one can see that in practise, the remittances have been strong even in a bad year like 2009.

[rajkphogat]

न्यू क्यूँकर जान दूं भैंस नै झोड़ में. भाई सै यो मेरा... अर फौगाट.

पर भाई सुन ले... या जो मन्नै smaat buoy/v. smaat buoy/v.v. smaat buoy कहा था, वा तेरी ताईं कोन्या था. वा तो smaat NRI ताईं था. पर तू राज्जी हो लिया, कोई बात ना... किम्मे खून तै बढ्या ही होगा.


अब और सुन लै... रेफेर समर's सिगनेचर... "as you think, so shall you become". तो भाई बात या सै अक इतना भी तू भांड कोन्या, बात सारी समझ ले सै. Bhai Braham Thoughts mentioned in post refered are beyond my imagination/thoughts so not to worry everything is okay wid me.

... अर और सुन, दिखे बुरा मन्ना मानिये, बड्डा भाई सूं तेरा, अक थोड़ी हाँ खिचाई भी कर ली... तो that is only in good humor. देख तेरी ताईं इस्माइली भी ला दी >>> Bhai mai bura kya e ka na maanya karu. Par je 5-7 saal pehlem kheech de e to thoda aur badh ja e eb kheechan ka k fayda.

p.s. : other replies to follow, later...

Bhai bhains chali b gayi te ulti kaad lyangey chinta ne se.

[rajkphogat]

Ek choti si baat mai bhi jodna chahta hu.

Dhull saab

As per ur formula what do u call the persons working in Foreign MNC's. MNC also earn money from india & take that outside india, they even do not pay tax properly thats why our govt. need to introduce MAT. And also as you know most of our Indian MNC's (PSU's TATA Rel etc.) are having overseas operations there they employed their citizens (providing employment oppu. to goras) what do you say them.
Why our govt. introduce special deductions to foreign cos. in early 90's to set up their operation in India. Eb nu na kahiye ek employment oppur. er tax revenue aawe se - MNC's me 4 aadmi ki jagah ek rakhey se er Tax kitni imaandari te de se wo b tanne bera hoga bhai.

Ritu ji

Merchant navy samaj me na aaya jara tafseel se batao aaj te aap gharney e howogi.
Muje ek baar ek aadmi ne kaha tha (who was in dubai & germany for almost 8 yrs) Bahar bahut paisa hai tum jitna kamana chahtey ho ussey b jyada par jo haal dilli me bihariyon ka hai us haal me rehna padega nahi to paisa bacha nahi paaogey.

Kapil Bhai

there is no doubt that Indian hav proved their metal in every part of world wherever they go, but some times i think If lakshmi mittal would hav been in India then we could get another Reliance Industries.

Jis aadmi ne jit Shanti mil ja wa jagah e sahi se. No one has any right to judge anyone, in my point of view.

[hsdhull]

jo apne ko indian samjhe wohi indian n jo apne to NRI kahe or soche teer maar diya unka main kuch nahi kar sakta

[yudhvirmor]

Dhull Sahab...

we don't argue here justa a heck of arguing or to prove something. I like Mukesh Ambani policy of "Amiri Badao"

Average NRI earns almost 5-6 times of his/her counterpart in India and they are creating a huge foreign reserve for country as mentioned above by Kapil.

Please refrain from dividing people on these lines of NRI Vs RI. We all are Indian first. Everybody has right to make his living in honourable way and we are just doing it outside India.

[upendersingh]

I like those NRIs-

Who don't change their name according to the foreign country (for example, someone's real name is Anand Pal, but he changes it to Andy Paul).

Who ask their children to not to follow the western culture and strictly ask them to follow Indian culture.

Who (young females specially) don't indulge in pornography or something alike stuffs.

Who (after making enough money) return back to their homeland and don't settle in foreign country for good.

Who make it to the top most post of foreign country, as President of Mauritius Anerood Jugnauth or President of Singapore S. R. Nathan.

Who are good human being despite having settled in foreign land.

[akshaymalik84]

No doubt that NRI are major contributors in our economy. But that is not because they love india but because they know that they will get good returns for each Penny they put in. NRIs are getting higher interest in Indian banks than in west. This does not concludes that NRIs are selfish or they don't like india. Infact 80% of NGO's funds are provided by NRIs. Their love to Indian sports,culture,bollywood etc.etc. is a confirmation of their affection to India(Not sure about Indian though). But its hard to take when they questions RIs capabilities. Not getting VISA approval, is an exhausted argument just like RIs one. And if it is a valid reason then why dont they write recommnedation latters for those whom VISA are denied.Help them! Make them like you.

It is very rude of we RIs to blame NRIs for everything wrong happening in India. Dont blame them, its RIs who creates these problems and only RIs have to solve them. Dont expect NRI to solve your problems. Make no doubt about it that most of RIs are waiting for their first opportunity to escape from this HELL just like those who had already escaped. We indians need somebody to blame, someone scapegoat for our own misdeeds, be it politicians, System, NRIs or RIs. We are just like that Argumentative.

[brahmtewatia]

Tewatia Ji, I can't put all links here as I don't have any complaint for those words. If any body tries to tease me saying that 'you are one-eyed or one-eared' then I can just laugh upon him because I am not. But if I am, then if someone says me then I have very good eyes or ears then I will fall upon him. But I will not disappoint you. I am putting such a link here. (Post no. 41 and 42 are concerned):
http://www.jatland.com/forums/showth...ut-India/page3

उपेंदर जी नमस्कार,

मैं यहाँ सपरिवार कुशल पूर्वक हूँ, और आशा करता हूँ की आप भी माँ चामुंडा देवी की कृपया से मंगलमय जीवन व्यतीत कर रहे होंगे. आपका पत्र (links) मिला. जानकार अत्यंत दुःख हुआ की आपकी भैंस कोई NRI खोल के ले गया. परन्तु यह जानकर बहुत ख़ुशी भी हुई कि आपने अभी अभी "हूगो बॉस" का काला चश्मा लिया है, जिस से आपको हर तरफ अब काला ही नज़र आता है.

... happen to go through, few of your enlightened posts and came to know of your malevolent opinion that you are carrying towards NRI's esp. after your post # 10 on neha chhikara thread.

let me bring down those posts # 41 & # 42 (in your links above) here for better explanation...

post 1 by mr. karan

... what I like about India...here is my list
1. When other civilizations were building pyramid, gargantuan towers -- India was developing society based on vedic values and character of humility. Believe in humanity, established the principle of Live and Let Live.
2. When rest of the world was busy in persecuting people for their beliefs, we gave them asylum and protection from persecution
3. When some misogynist, delusional, uneducated, suffering from little man syndrome desert nomad was preaching hatered we were building universities where education about pursuit of happiness was taught and debated. Our universities were teaching the path of nirvana that was not based on dogma but on karma.
........................
We Indians are emotional people, we want to live in history and nostalgia, we aspire for some utopian nation, we are the people who never want to face reality. Reality of this nation is diametrically opposite to our Vedic History. We are among the most cruel, self serving, back stabbing, treacherous, low self esteem, lacking any pride, strength, character and moral values, manipulative among our peers in this world. We never get tired of preaching and sermonizing others.

post 2 by brahmtewatia

india, indeed was a country of universal love, sanctity and faith with well behaved people. the mystery of indian myths and indian art lies partly in the fact that it suggests rather than states. the cultural inheritance of India has always intrigued and attracted the world. the richness and the diversity of its cultural heritage and traditions have been popular in all ages across the world. not to forget its striking architecture, majestic royal palaces and their beauty that has been an integral part of our heritage offering a deep insight into our bountiful past.

its a pity to learn tht this is my country now... it's just like nowhere else on earth - a sensory overload... utterly chaotic nd bursting with unruly energy with people full of false pride and ego... sad, but true !!!

these posts are now divided into two colors... red (bold and letter size increased) and black. i assume that this time with your new, black "hugo boss" glasses you wont be able to read in black... and would read only that, what is written in bold red.

तो भाईसाहब आगे समाचार यह है जैसा कि आप जान ही गए होंगे... कि प्लीज अपना "हूगो बॉस" का काला चश्मा उतारिये... and try to see the positive part of an individual's opinion. secondly, what is written (now in black) is also true, even those die-hard anti-NRI's too have admitted... on this very thread.

... more to follow

[brahmtewatia]

उपेंदर जी... you are most welcome to send more links, i'll try my best to take off your काला चश्मा.

[brahmtewatia]

[Got introduced in this thread just by appreciating Kapil (NRI)'s post and somehow as anti-NRI.]

भाई सुनील, ये तो भौतही बड़ा कीराइम कर दिया आपने... अब गोली खाओ.

[brahmtewatia]

And then there are people like me who really wanna go back..inevitably inviting looks like "Are you nuts?..must be outta your mind..giving up all this ."...!

Having said that I do believe in 'oneness' across the globe ...physical boundaries...ummmm ..should be the last priority..And agree with Kapil..pretty much everything..

... well can't comment on yr reasons, but i would like to see your same opinion after few years.

racism, globalization, 'oneness' across the globe... must be somehow inter-linked... just thoughts.

[upendersingh]

उपेंदर जी... you are most welcome to send more links, i'll try my best to take off your काला चश्मा.

तेवतिया जी, अगर ऐसे तर्क देकर आप मेरी आँखों पर चढ़ा काला चश्मा उतारना चाहोगे तो मुझे तो अपनी आँखों की रोशनी जाने का खतरा पैदा हो जाएगा. मैंने आपकी जिन पोस्ट का हवाला दिया था वे 23.12.09 की हैं, जबकि आपने मेरी जिस पोस्ट का हवाला दिया है वो 14.01.10 की है. इसका मतलब आपने ये क्यों नहीं लगाया कि जब अपने अप्रवासी भाइयों को मैंने भारत के बारे में उलटी-सीधी बातें करते देखा तो मेरी वो पोस्ट उसकी प्रतिक्रिया भर थी और वो भी सही तर्क के साथ. आपने जो बात रेड की हैं वो आपने अतीत की बात कही है और वो भी एक तरह से हम भारतीयों को नीचा दिखाने का ही एक प्रयास कहा जाना चाहिए.

[upendersingh]

I don't like those NRIs who decide or decided to head abroad just because they consider India a HELL. The performance (mode of living life) of this whole world is almost same and that's why the result of whole world's life is also almost same. Generally, an average poor person in India gets birth, does childish mischieves in childhood, does sex hunting in youth, then get married and then starts enjoying the ailments whole of his life and then dies. NRIs or natives of foreign country are no different. Are they able in foreign land to avoid ailments, grieves, stress and finally death? If any person has all of his dear and near ones around he feels happy (be it rich or poor), but if one doesn't, then even a billions of dollars can't get him happiness or peace of mind.
So if someone has settled in abroad just because of this thought that India is a hell, then I am sorry to say where he has moved life is a hell there too.
This characterstic of life
'human being will take birth > then grow child > then youth > then half-aged > then old and then die,
puts the whole world in same tub. Same tub full of filthy water.
Though no one is going to employ me on billions dollar p.a. but if someone offers then I will reject the offer and prefer to live in India. As a tourist I would like to tour whole world though if I ever be able.

[ritu]

who cares for your liking or disliking upender ji.ppl are selfish be it a RI or NRI.ones self liking or liking of the ppl who are related to him matters.no body is bothered what x,y and z likes or not

I don't like those NRIs who decide or decided to head abroad just because they consider India a HELL. The performance (mode of living life) of this whole world is almost same and that's why the result of whole world's life is also almost same. Generally, an average poor person in India gets birth, does childish mischieves in childhood, does sex hunting in youth, then get married and then starts enjoying the ailments whole of his life and then dies. NRIs or natives of foreign country are no different. Are they able in foreign land to avoid ailments, grieves, stress and finally death? If any person has all of his dear and near ones around he feels happy (be it rich or poor), but if one doesn't, then even a billions of dollars can't get him happiness or peace of mind.
So if someone has settled in abroad just because of this thought that India is a hell, then I am sorry to say where he has moved life is a hell there too.
This characterstic of life
'human being will take birth > then grow child > then youth > then half-aged > then old and then die,
puts the whole world in same tub. Same tub full of filthy water.
Though no one is going to employ me on billions dollar p.a. but if someone offers then I will reject the offer and prefer to live in India. As a tourist I would like to tour whole world though if I ever be able.

[Vgahlout]

Sareeeeeeeeeeeee Bavleee hoyee lag re h ......apne admi chugarde k hone chahiyeee ...................taki kal n kite jaaave t datan ka ar rotiii paniii ka jugad hojaveeee ...........

Ar koi kite chala javeeeee apne desh ka admi nahi badal sakta kite na kite apne ali kar ke maneeeeeeeeeeeeegaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa:rock :rock:rock:rock:rock

[upendersingh]

जाटों की सबसे बड़ी विडम्बना रही है अपनी ही गाल में खूंड बजान की… or at least I think so ! period !

This topic has been कुलबुलाइंग (intriguing) my mind for quite some time, as often times then not, i see a very biased opinion(s) by many fellow resident indian JATlanders. may be it’s a kind of frustration that they couldn’t managed to make it overseas or too much attachment with their families… I don’t know… honestly, i really don’t know (pls. dont shoot me for that). as a result, they never miss a chance to crack their volley of missiles every time a related issue pops-up. be it the ‘interrogation of shahrukh khan’ or any NRI behaviour justifying racism or whatever…

do these NRI’s committed a sin, when they left home ?

(forget about the contribution they have made towards the growth of india, when they got good opportunity to show their skills/expertise from abroad).

would like to invite fellow members to share there views (… or frustration) on the subject. i would also like to know the contribution of NRI’s to Indian economy. at the same time, i would also like to know of instances where NRI's have brought disgrace to indian community by their misdeeds.

... and >>> would like to invite, especially mr dhull (>>> and similar mindsets) whose derogatory remarks on NRI's - "dhobi ke kutte, na ghar ke na ghaat ke" on the thread ‘what do you like about india’ post # 88 (link >>> http://www.jatland.com/forums/showthread.php?29200-What-do-you-like-about-India&p=239024&viewfull=1#post239024) to write his/their opinion here (at least 10 pages, if not 100).

When I wrote that post during that this thought came in my mind that who cares what I like or dislike but then I had an answer for that. The thread starter had asked the JLers to share their views about the NRIs. That's what I did.
मैंने केवल अपने मन की भड़ास निकाली.

[shailendra]

I hate silly kind of RI’s that "leaking like a faulty faucet" spill deadly venom on public forums passing holy judgment on folks (that they probably think they know very well only by watching ShahRukh Khan/Karan Johar cliched movies)… judgmental about mostly successful folks who they themselves would rather emulate at the drop of a hat (...hmmm, in some quarters quite aptly termed as ‘jealousy’ maybe?):rolleyes:

Then I definitely dislike, in fact pity those pathetic kind of RI’s that with their limited, narrow mindset (and “Sainik” like tendencies) generalize the whole Diaspora and in the process unfortunately very much bracket (and categorize,marginalize) a whole majority of the larger (and the much better informed/intelligent) RI populace!... [doing nobody a favor; least of all their own fellow countrymen residing, living and working peacefully in India.]

…and oh btw, I also hate cocky, good-for-nothing, lazy, and frustrated RI’s that- rather than be happy for - preach, ***** and moan freely (phokatt mein) about their own countrymen, especially the ones who reside abroad, ...just before they themselves (grudgingly? yeah right!) would head out to the local flashy new mall to buy Nike shoes for ‘junior’ who of course has to conform with the latest western outfits in his english-speaking schools (and when has to go frequent those pseudo pool/bowling alleys & discotheques with westernized/chic' friends) in order to stand up to the local peer pressure (also the one that they complain to their neighbors about, the brat who doesn't seem to listen to their cultural ‘preaching’s’ anymore….”Aare kya karun Mishra saab, yo chorra to haat sae likad gaya hai!”)… so, where’s all this 'I hate NRI's' frustration coming from, eh?...Hmmm...everything okay at home? (what?...can’t seem to find a ‘well-settled NRI chorra’ for the daughter)???***
…[Well, how about also starting a post that goes something like, “I (quietly) hate all those Indian kids that want to go study/work abroad…………………. and follow in the steps of their more illustrious Jat aunty/uncles (over their ‘loser’ dad)" ]???


-------


***[No, please, …please save me any statistics and percentage calculations on such (obviously) 1 for 1 loaded statements…!]....…

[pradeepsuhag]

I went through the complete thread. so much has been said here for and against the NRIs.
I have spent most of my time in India. It has been just 3 years since m in Toulouse (though I've been to US occasionally 2-3 times during my working tenure in India).
I have experienced working both in India and Outside. The working environment, the people, the facilities and all. But yes I have to admit one thing here ki jo maja, jo apnapan apne desh me hai kite bhi koni bhai! (Ib NRI bhai mere pache mat lagiyo. jo mane lage se wo e likhya se. opinions differ person to person )

Coming back to OP, let me start with a little stat. On JL only few thousand members are there (14k) and out of which active members are only around 2000. Usme se bhi kuch log post nahi dalte honge yaha per. they might just come, read and go away. So people who criticise NRIs are very less in number.. (correct me if i'm thinking erratically ) So why to bother about those people????

Now the point raised by Shailendar bhai....VISA... It couldn't be a single reason that people living in India and not able to move to other continents (Europe, Aus or America) always scold NRIs only becoz they did not get Visa! (For me its unjustice to those who really admire NRIs for their efforts and growth).Visa, I agree, can be one of the reason for some FRUSTRATED person (jo 2-3 bar fail ho gya visa lene ki koshish me :D), but not the only reason. (Bhai aapka view point mere se different ho sakta hia ) Such people are really very less in number.. Ye wo log hote hai jo bahar sirf paise kamaane ke liye jana chahte hai par ja nahi paate.

Many people just don't want to leave their motherland. I can site at least 2 examples from my friend circle for that. Both rejected working in US just because they never wanted to go abroad for work purpose. And believe me they are well settled and leading a VERY good life in India.
Bhai Koi jana chahta hai aur uske pas jane ke paise na ho to kaise jaye? Lack of money is another reason for that. Is baat ke liye wo dusro ko gali de, that does not sound good to me at least. Er koe deta bhi hoga to diye jao.. apni e jabaan kaali karega

Aur kayi logo ko to bahar jaane ka vichar hi dimag me nahi aata. Wo to bus yahi sochte hai ki "re kyuker e koi naukri lag jao,ghar aale bhi raji ho jange er byah bhi ho jaga suthri dhaal"

Kuch logo ki parivarik majburi bhi ho skti hia.Though number of such people is less. Par kuch log isliye nahi jate ki unke jane ke baad gharwalo ki care kon karega.

Aur 80% NRIs desh ke bahar kaise jate hai ya kya karte hai desh ke bahar jaa ke ye bataane ki jarurat nahi hai sahayad.

Sab ek jaise nahi hote, aur sab log bura bhi nahi sochte. Mujhe degree ki starting se hi UK jake Post graduation ki dhun swar thi. But I was not able to show up the required amount in my account and hence couldn't make it. It was a dream shattered for me, but i din start abusing other people who went Out to pursue their career or studies further. I took it as my luck and worked hard. And 3 years back I moved to France for better career.
And just for info for my frens living in India I've donated some amount for a school building in my village. Bhai yaha baith ke main bilding to nahi bna sakta, par thoda contribution avshay kar sakta hu and i did that to satisy my inner soul that at least I'm doing a bit (very small though) for my country.

Abusing NRIs is something that we don't have a hold on. Jo log ye kahte hai ki NRIs desh ke liye kuch nahi karte (may be true in their thinking terms), wo ye sochte hai ki sirf paisa hi ek matr udeshay hai NRI ban-ne ke piche. 80% cases I'll agree to them. Jo log bahar taxi chalane ke liye jate hai, ya kisi restaurant me waiter bane rahte hai unki terms me ye thinking sahi hai..I'm not commenting on their family's financial situation here. Kisi ki achi hoti hai kisi ki thik thak or jiski buri hoti hai wo to sapne hi le sakta hai bahar jane ke..Jiski achi hoti hai usko bahar jaake waiter ban-ne ki jarurat nahi hoti. Er jo ghar-bar bech ke jave se dusre desh unke dhore or koi naukri hoti nahi karne ke liye.. so waiter ya kutta ghumaniya ban jave se. (I've seen few Indians here doing this crap!). And when I asked, they replied ke kuch to karna e padega bahar aake.. ghar ne pise bhi to bhejne se..

Par baki 20% ka kya? They move out for better career prospects, for better knowledge and better lifestyle. Par ye baat un logo ke samjh me nahi aati jo NRIs ko koste hai, unko swarthi bolte hai.. Un ne kun btave ke bhai swarthi sab hove hai. koi ghna koe thoda..

And lets not abuse our country also. Its our motherland and we owe our life to it. Sirf NRIs ke wapis jane se desh ki haalat nahi sudhar sakti. Sabko milkar hi kuch karna hoga tabhi desh sudhar sakta hai. And I request all members that we should refrain from using bad words about our country (this i noticed in few posts here) or our country people in a social forum like this. Its visible to whole world.

Maine Kapil bhai ki post padhi and found the sentence very much apt(i've quoted that in my previous post). Jiska jit anjal-pani hoga wo ude e javega. Na kise ke maru-maru kare te kise ki kismat badle er na kise ke toone kare te kise ka punjhad paatte!!
Isliye jo jaha hai wo wha pe khush raho.. Er main to roj tadke sanjh hath jod ke ram te sab khatir prarthna karya karu ke "Hey Ram, sabne 2 tam ki roti de, er mane 3 tam ki!!"

PS :
1. Ib koe sa mere pachhe mogre le ke na bhaj liyo, ak bahar baithya baithya itna bada bhaasan chep gya main
2. These are all my personal opinions based on my own experience. Others may differ!

[akshaymalik84]

Par baki 20% ka kya? They move out for better career prospects, for better knowledge and better lifestyle. Par ye baat un logo ke samjh me nahi aati jo NRIs ko koste hai, unko swarthi bolte hai.. Un ne kun btave ke bhai swarthi sab hove hai. koi ghna koe thoda..

Just a thought......Rest 80% doesn't write here(jo taxi chalawe hai ya waiter ka kaam kare hai..). That leaves 20% BETTER LIFESTYLE NRIs with better knoweledge whom egos got hurt by some stupid remarks in another thread.