No one is saying that Naxals movement or the goverment's way of handling it is right (or wrong), just because Arundhati Roy has said (or not said) so. Arundhati Roy has brought the other side fo the view to us. Agreed, she may have injected it with her own views through her command over English literature. But that's not the issue being discussed. So there is not point debating about Arundhati Roy.
PS: About the Nuclear policy. After the disintegration of Russia, America does not have any fear of an attack by Russia and hence does not need to spend such huge money to maintain all the nuclear arsenal that it has. So, it is very logical for America to dismantle those nuclear weapons. However, after dismantling, dumping that nuclear material in America would also incur huge money and is a big risk. So it decides to dump it in the global dumping ground (India). And the best part for America is that, it would earn millions of dollars for dumping it. Isn't that "sone pe shuhaga for America"? To facilitate all this, Indian government brings in the Nuclear policy - building more nuclear reactors. That is when the whole world is dismantling them because of their risk to human life. On top of it, it is now capping the maximum compensation paid in case of a nuclear accident.
Has the government forgotten about the Bhopal gas victims? My dear PM, after so many years, they are still asking for justice? What was there fault? Wouldn't they have been alive if they had not allowed setting up of that carbide plant in their city?
PSS: This is also not the issue being discussed. You brought it up and I could not resist myself.