Jitender,
First of all let me express my appreciation for devoting your precious time and energy for a good cause. Also you have given a very positive twist to this discussion. I have gone through the proposed modus operandii and would like to add my input which may be read in bold and italics and the same may not be construed as a pro-corruption stance.
(a) Any person who was ever chargesheeted for any offence under IPC or PC Act or was ever penalized under CCS Conduct Rules.
Often honest and upright officials are framed invoking false Conduct Rules. First of all we need to have a holistic review of these sacred rules.
(b) Any person who is less than 40 years in age.
This age limit also doesn’t seem to be backed by any scientific logic. There are people who may not be mature even at the age of 60 but there could be others who attain maturity at the age of 25.
4. A selection committee consisting of the following shall be set up:
a. Two senior most judges of Supreme Court
What is the guarantee; Senior Supreme Court Judges are free from corruption. They may not be directly accepting bribes but recently the son-in-law of the Chief Justice was in news for possessing property disproportionate of his income.
b. Two senior most Chief Justices of High Courts.
Former Haryana CM Bhajan lal was able to buy the loyalty of a few judges by offering them HUDA plots.
c. All Nobel Laureates of Indian Origin
A Nobel laureate may be a hero in the eyes of Nobel Committee as well as the influential world lobby but could be a traitor in the opinion of his own countrymen. Recent Chinese Nobel laureate is a case in point. Difficult to decide who is right?
d. Last three Magsaysay Award winners
Again, not very authentic criteria. A poor farmer in a remote village hardly sends any nominee for this award. (However, I know Kiran Bedi was a right choice for this award.)
d. The list of candidates along with their recommendations received in the format
mentioned above shall be displayed on a website.
How will the villagers who do not have access to internet will express their opinion?