isse hi brahanwaad kahte hai..aadhi -adhuri jaankari ko tarod marod ke pesh karna ( kisi faayde ke liye ya aise hi.)..jo brahamano ne puran main kiya... aur usse likhkar pakka kar diya...aaj in purano ka hi hawal dete hai brahman aur aap hum jaise log usse galat kahte hai... ...agar yeh lekh jo sangwaan sahab ne likhi hai gaam main un logo ke pass jaaye jinhe history ka jyada kuch pata nahi ya research karne ke kam option hai..to we bus isse hi sach maan lenge...ab main aapko batata huin kaise..
Agreed ki tod marod ki jaankari pesh karna brahmanwaad hai n history ka to mujhe bhi aap jitna nhi pta bhai and na hi maine isse pathar ki lakeer mana. ek sawaal h n uspe sochane mein kya buraai hai n what is wrong if it is JL? aur article mein likha bhi hai ki sodh ka vishay , dont you think that answer some of the questions?
1. "Jat the ancient rulers" was written by Bhim singh dahiay ji..jo ki ek almost ek revolutionay work tha..but many of his findings are based on assumptions.. ..many thinsg are very controversial..
ab aap thoda yeh padho...
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Goths
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alaric_I
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Massagatae
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alans
Sure, i ll read.
2. jats have connection/or not with Gatae( scythians) , jutes, alans, or goths (alarik jat mentioned was a goth) or with all of them..this is very controversial and historains has different view on that...to agar sangwaan sahab ne alarik (
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alaric_I
) ko seedhe jat bana hi diya to kam se kam yeh to likh hi sakte the ki wo ek goth tha aur juch historain Goth ko jaat maante hai...wo ek historain to hai nahi jo unke pass pramaan hain..ek book hi to padhi hai..yeh to wahi baat ho gayi jaise brahman ek puraan padhte hai aur kahte hai usme jo likha hai bas wahi sach hai...ab sangwaan saahb bhi bilkul aisa hi kar rahe hai...aur agar aadhi adhuri jaankari thi to histoy ko beech main lekar kyoun aaye..so how is it different from brahanwaad??
I would suggest, give his suggestion directly to him or i ll convey the same when i ll meet him.
3. ab sabse badi assumption..upper aale sab jugaad bhidakar wo sonia gandhi ko jaatni sidh karne pe utaaru hain..yeh aapko sensible lagta hai.??......aap logical baat karte ho maine dekha hai aaj tak..par yaha kya ho gaya..kya aap hi to wo andhe bahgat nahi ban rahe!!..aap khud bhi kuch kar liya karo (aapne yeh salaah beech main koodkar gulia ko di thi jabki wo writer se reference maang raha tha!!, kya sangwan sahb se pooche gaye har sawwl ka jawaab appne aur sura ji ne hi dena jaroori hai ..chahe pata ho ya na..)....aapne historical tathyo ka kitna adhyan kiya?.....kuch hadh tak cheeze theek hoti hai..par!!
As i said above i have not talked about the content of article once and when i replied to ygulia that was purely intentional n i have not answered every question but the only to ygulia.
4. agar sangwaan sahab sonia ko vote karana chahte hai to wo seedha kyoun nahi bolte ki agar wo reservation deti hai to subko vote do aur sab log ko yeh baat theek lagegei...kaan ko ghumakar kyoun pakda jaa reh hai..aap ko kya ab bhi nahi dikha ki brahanwaad haawi ho raha hai .......
i reiterate "
I would suggest, give his suggestion directly to him or i ll convey the same when i ll meet him."
5. aakhri baat..aap ka kya vichaar hai..jato ko sonia /congress ko support karna chaiye ya nahi...aaj tak aapke write-up ke yeh aabhaas hua hai ki aap modi ke kaam se prabhavit hai ..aur modi ke liye aapne logical tarq bhi diye hai..ya arcticle padhe hai aap bhi soniya ke bahgat ho gaye
Bhai main prabhavit to kisi se nhi hota n kisi ka andh bhagat hun, bhagat sirf Ch chhoturam or Bhaagt singh ka hun. aur jo discussion huye hain usme modi ka kaam pe dusron k addhar pe opinion maine dia hai dusron ki tarah n maine to congress ki RTI n MNREGA ka bhi samarthan dia hai ( infact advani ne bhi MNREGA ko acha batya tha to kya vo congress ka supporte ho gya?) rhi meri baat to vaise to voting secret hoti hai lekin abhi jaton ko center mein OBC mein reservation milta hait o i ll vote for them without doubt atleast this time.
PS- logically jawaab dena bhai..aapse ay sangwaan sahab se koi niji/political duhmani nahi hai..bas seedhe-seedhe sawaall pooch liye.